Share 
State of Play’s TL;DR
- Prediction market manipulation was the top discussion topic at the CFTC’s first Innovation Advisory Committee meeting.
- Participants pointed out several markets that are open to abuse.
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s first Innovation Advisory Committee meeting put prediction market manipulation at the center of the discussion, a notable development for platforms operating in the fast-growing gambling-adjacent space.
Around 30 executives from prediction market platforms, sports betting operators, exchanges, and crypto firms attended the session, according to Casino.com. Companies mentioned in the report included Kalshi, Polymarket, FanDuel Predicts, CME Group, and Coinbase.
Executives debate how vulnerable some contracts may be
CME Group CEO Terry Duffy said some markets are especially exposed to abuse.
“There are a lot of things susceptible to manipulation.”
He also said that since President Donald Trump took office in January 2025, there have been 2,500 self-certifications and none have been opposed. Duffy said some of those self-certifications “no doubt” violated Core Principle 3, the standard tied to manipulation.
CFTC Chairman Michael Selig pushed back on one example involving trading tied to Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro. Selig said those products were not listed, never were listed, the trading happened offshore, and the related reporting was “fake news.”
Recent cases highlighted the enforcement concerns
Casino.org pointed to several incidents that have fueled scrutiny around prediction markets. One involved former Trump teleprompter operator Gabriel Perez, who was reported to have made tens of thousands of dollars from “Mentions” markets tied to Trump speeches. ABC News said Perez was in talks with federal regulators to settle allegations that he used inside knowledge to win more than $100,000.
Another example involved US Army Master Sergeant Gannon Ken Van Dyke, who was said to have used classified information to generate nearly a half-million dollars in profit related to the capture of Maduro. Former Congressman George Santos was fined $35,000 for manipulating a contract related to his appearance at the State of the Union address.
Coinbase proposes a test for controversial markets
Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong suggested a three-part framework for evaluating contracts:
- Whether a market creates public harm
- Whether there is a direct causal link between the market and that harm
- How susceptible the contract is to manipulation
Armstrong said it is risky when an outcome can be determined by one person. But he also cautioned against overcorrecting, arguing that in some cases the public benefit of a market could outweigh manipulation concerns.
Based on reporting by Richard Janvrin for Casino.com.
