Share 
Attorney General Letitia James has launched a civil action against Valve Corp., claiming the company’s sale of “loot boxes” amounts to unlawful gambling under state law. The lawsuit focuses on several of Valve’s most popular franchises, including Counter-Strike, Dota 2, and Team Fortress.
The 2026 legal challenge to Valve’s business model
The complaint, filed in New York County Supreme Court on Feb. 25, 2026, challenges Valve’s business model for these games. It alleges the company profits by selling players “chances” to obtain valuable virtual items, violating both the New York State Constitution and state penal law.
The state is bringing the case under Executive Law Section 63(12), a statute used to prosecute repeated illegal conduct in business. The filing identifies Valve as a Washington-based corporation that operates Steam, one of the world’s largest PC game distribution platforms.
Why loot boxes are defined as gambling
The state’s case turns on a straightforward framing: users pay money for a random outcome where the reward has real-world value.
According to the lawsuit, Valve sells loot boxes—virtual containers that award one random item—and often charges users for a “key” required to open them. While the items are mostly cosmetic, used to decorate weapons or characters, the state argues they can be worth significant sums. Rare items are described in the filing as worth “thousands of dollars.”
Because most openings produce common items worth only pennies, the complaint says users typically pay to open boxes for the same reason people buy lottery tickets: the possibility of landing a high-value prize. New York calls the arrangement “quintessential gambling.”
Steam Marketplace and cash-like liquidity
The filing argues that Valve built an ecosystem that gives these prizes cash-like liquidity.
According to the complaint, Valve allows users to sell virtual items on the Steam Community Market. Proceeds go into a Steam Wallet, which can be used to buy hardware, games, other virtual items, or more loot box keys. The state also alleges that items can be sold for cash on third-party marketplaces.
The complaint states that virtual items bought and sold through these markets have tangible monetary value, citing an estimate that the market for Counter-Strike virtual items alone has reached “billions of dollars.”
Slot machine design and underage gambling risks
New York also targets the sensory design of the loot boxes. In Counter-Strike, the complaint says opening a box resembles a virtual or online slot machine, featuring a scrolling “wheel” that cycles through items before stopping.
The filing alleges the animation creates a “near miss” effect by appearing to stop just short of a high-value reward. The state argues these “psychological lures” are similar to casino gambling and carry risks of addiction.
Another major section of the complaint focuses on children and teenagers. The filing alleges that Valve’s loot boxes are popular with minors and that the risks of gambling mechanics are heightened for adolescents.
One example describes a report Valve received regarding the alleged theft of virtual items from the account of an 11-year-old. The complaint notes there is no indication Valve closed the child’s account or took action based on the subscriber agreement’s age requirements.
Restitution, fines and requested relief
The complaint alleges Valve has made “tens of millions of dollars” selling keys to thousands of New Yorkers, plus millions more in market commissions. It notes that the parties entered tolling agreements that paused limitations periods from April 5, 2023, through Feb. 6, 2026.
The lawsuit lists three main legal theories:
- Violations of New York’s constitutional gambling prohibition.
- Promoting gambling in the second degree.
- Promoting gambling in the first degree.
For the felony count, the complaint cites the statutory threshold for “bookmaking”-style conduct, which includes accepting more than five bets totaling more than $5,000 in a single day. The state alleges Valve repeatedly met that threshold.
New York is asking the court to permanently bar Valve from violating state gambling laws and is seeking restitution, damages, and the disgorgement of profits. The state is also seeking a fine equal to three times the amount Valve allegedly gained under state penal law.
